W-2 vs 1099 — Key Differences
Employee vs independent contractor: tax implications, benefits, legal tests, and what form you should receive for your work situation.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | W-2 Employee | 1099 Contractor |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Withholding | Employer withholds automatically | You pay taxes yourself |
| Self-Employment Tax | Employer pays half (7.65%) | You pay full 15.3% |
| Benefits | Health insurance, 401k, PTO, sick leave | None — responsible for own benefits |
| Work Control | Employer controls when/where/how | You control methods and schedule |
| Business Expenses | Cannot deduct (TCJA eliminated) | Deduct on Schedule C |
| Equipment | Employer provides tools/equipment | Use your own tools and equipment |
| Multiple Clients | Typically one employer at a time | Can work for many clients |
| Tax Form Received | Form W-2 (annual) | Form 1099-NEC (if paid $600+) |
| Unemployment Insurance | Eligible for unemployment | Not eligible |
| Workers Compensation | Covered by employer | Your responsibility |
W-2 Employee
1099 Contractor
Tax Implications Comparison
What Gets Withheld:
- • Federal income tax (based on W-4)
- • Social Security tax: 6.2% (up to $168,600 in 2024)
- • Medicare tax: 1.45% (all wages)
- • State income tax (if applicable)
- • Local taxes (some cities)
Example: $60,000 Salary
Federal tax withheld: ~$8,000
Social Security (6.2%): $3,720
Medicare (1.45%): $870
Employee pays: ~$12,590
Employer also pays $4,590 (their half of SS/Medicare)
✓ Advantages:
- • Taxes paid throughout year (no surprises)
- • Employer pays half of SS/Medicare
- • Potential refund if overwitheld
- • Simpler tax return (just report W-2)
What You Pay:
- • Self-employment tax: 15.3% (SS + Medicare)
- • Federal income tax (based on profit)
- • State income tax
- • Quarterly estimated payments required
- • No withholding — all paid by you
Example: $60,000 1099 Income
Gross income: $60,000
Business expenses: -$10,000
Net profit: $50,000
Self-employment tax (15.3%): $7,650
Income tax (~22% bracket): $11,000
Total taxes: ~$18,650
✓ Advantages:
- • Deduct business expenses (reduces taxable income)
- • Retirement contributions reduce taxes
- • Potential QBI deduction (20% of profit)
- • More control over tax planning
Tax Burden Reality Check
1099 contractors typically pay MORE total tax than W-2 employees at same income level because:
- • You pay both employer AND employee portions of SS/Medicare (15.3% vs 7.65%)
- • Must make quarterly estimated payments (penalties if you don't)
- • No employer withholding means larger tax bill at filing time
- • Even with business deductions, total tax often higher than W-2
Contractors need to charge 30-40% more than equivalent W-2 salary to compensate for higher taxes and lack of benefits.
Which Form Should You Receive?
IRS Classification Test
IRS uses these three factors to determine if you're employee (W-2) or contractor (1099):
Behavioral Control
Does company control:
- • When you work?
- • Where you work?
- • How you do the work?
- • What tools/equipment to use?
- • Training provided?
More control = Employee (W-2)
Financial Control
Do you have:
- • Significant investment in equipment?
- • Unreimbursed expenses?
- • Opportunity for profit/loss?
- • Services available to market?
- • Set your own rates?
More independence = Contractor (1099)
Relationship Type
Is there:
- • Written contract?
- • Benefits provided?
- • Ongoing relationship?
- • Key business activity?
- • Permanency expected?
Permanent + benefits = Employee (W-2)
You Should Get W-2 If:
Company sets your schedule and tells you when to work. You work at their office/location. They provide equipment, computer, tools. You can only work for them (exclusivity). They train you on their methods. You get employee benefits. You're integral to their business operations. It's an ongoing, permanent relationship.
You Should Get 1099-NEC If:
You set your own hours and work independently. You work from your own location. You use your own equipment and tools. You work for multiple clients/customers. You invoice for completed work or projects. No benefits provided. You're hired for specific projects, not permanent role. You have own business entity (LLC, etc.).
Worker Misclassification
What is Misclassification?
Employer treats you as 1099 contractor (giving 1099-NEC) when you should legally be W-2 employee. This is common practice by businesses trying to avoid payroll taxes, benefits costs, and employment law obligations. It's illegal and harms workers by shifting tax burden and eliminating benefits.
Signs You're Misclassified:
- Company controls schedule: You must work specific hours at their location
- Can't work for others: Exclusivity clause prevents other clients
- They provide all equipment: Use company computer, phone, tools
- Ongoing permanent work: Not project-based, expect to work indefinitely
- Hourly or salary pay: Paid by hour/week vs per project or deliverable
What to Do If Misclassified:
File IRS Form SS-8
Request IRS determination of worker status. IRS investigates and rules whether you should be employee or contractor. Takes 6+ months but creates official classification.
File Form 8919
Report uncollected Social Security and Medicare tax on your return. Reduces your self-employment tax burden by employer's share they should have paid. Flags misclassification to IRS.
State Labor Board Complaint
Report to state labor department. May result in employer investigation, back taxes, penalties. Could lead to unemployment insurance eligibility and workers compensation coverage.
Consult Employment Attorney
Misclassification may support wage/hour claims, benefits recovery, or wrongful termination cases. Potential damages for unpaid overtime, missed benefits, additional taxes you paid.
W-2 vs 1099 FAQs
Related Resources
Explore more paystub solutions for your specific needs
Need the Right Tax Form?
Generate professional W-2 forms for employees or 1099-NEC for contractors. IRS-compliant documentation for every work situation.